Vanilla Custard Ice Cream

 

The truth behind this recipe is that I’m not a huge fan of ice cream. But this made me change my mind!

 

 

If asked whether ice cream is a year-round treat or a summer treat, I am totally a summer treat kind of gal. It just feels like it should be warm enough outside to justify it. The creamy cold treat is so satisfying in the summer.

 

 

I realized the best way to enjoy ice cream more is to start making it myself. Now I can control the ingredients and balances and ratios and hit the mark with every bite!

 

 

Of course, vanilla is just the base. There are so many things you can add to this to customize it. That’s also a big selling point for me. I like bits and bites in my ice cream, but hubby is more of a purist and would rather have the simple and pure vanilla.

 

This recipe is tailored for a Kitchenaid ice cream maker attachment. It makes the right amount for the size of the bowl. Just be aware if there’s any changes you want to make. I have used it in the Cuisenart ice cream maker too and it worked wonderfully.

 

Vanilla Custard Ice Cream

 

5 large egg yolks

1 c granulated sugar, divided

2 whole vanilla beans (or you can use 2 tsp vanilla bean paste)

1 ¾ c whole milk (or use an equal blend of half and half with 2% milk)

2 ¼ c heavy cream

1/8 tsp salt

 

In a bowl, combine the egg yolks with ¼ c sugar. Whisk together for about 3 minutes, it should lighten up in color and feel liquid-like. Meanwhile, in a sauce pan warm up the milk to 165. I use a candy thermometer to help as I don’t want it to boil. Split the vanilla beans and scrap them. Add that to the milk, along with the vanilla bean pods.

 

Once the milk has reached 165, pull it off the burner. Slowly pour ½ cup at a time into the egg mixture, being sure to whisk the whole time while incorporating. Continue doing this until you have about 1 ½ cups of milk added to the eggs. Then pour the egg-milk mixture back into the saucepan. Add the rest of the sugar, salt, and the heavy cream and heat it back up to 165, stirring occasionally.

 

Have a bowl or large measuring cup ready to pour the hot mixture into and once it’s reached 165, take it off the heat. Pour it into your bowl or large measuring cup and let it cool for a few minutes before covering it with plastic and placing it into the refrigerator. It needs to cool completely before it can be made into ice cream, so at least 12 hours, but best to let it chill over night. Also, if you haven’t already, make sure your ice cream maker bowl is in the freezer. It will need at least 24 hours in there for it to be ready for use.

 

I use a Kitchenaid mixer for my ice cream maker so the following directions are based off of that. The timing should be similar on most ice cream makers, but be familiar with your equipment when reaching this step.

 

Set the frozen ice cream bowl on the mixing stand. Set up the paddle and connection pieces and turn on the machine to the low setting (no more than a 2). Slowly pour the custard into the ice cream maker while it’s on. Make sure to get all the vanilla bean spreckles into the mixer. Let it do its work for about 20-30 minutes. You’ll see the ice cream start to fluff up and become more full. 

 

 

Your ice cream is ready when it starts to work its way up the mixing bowl and look creamy and fluffy. The Kitchenaid connection piece also starts to click which is a sign its done. The ice cream will resemble a soft serve at this point. Remove the ice cream from the mixing bowl into a freezer safe container using a plastic spatula or a wooden spoon (don’t use metal as it can damage the bowl). Put the ice cream in the freezer once more. The ice cream will become firmer in the freezer. It only needs a couple of hours and it is ready to enjoy.